14. Department of Health and Human Services · Notable
Withdraw funding from entities that violate conscience laws
Printed page 494 14. Department of Health and Human Services
“HHS should withdraw funding from any violating entities that refuse to correct their behavior, and OCR CRFD should work with ASFR to ensure that all grant announcements and instruments inform grantees and applicants of their obligations to comply with federal health care conscience laws specifically as a condition of obtaining or maintaining their funding.”
What has happened
- Partially done
OMB, with HHS among 43 co-proposing agencies, proposed to revise the government-wide grants regulation at 2 CFR 200.300 so that the non-discrimination language in Federal awards expressly covers religion and conscience, so that compliance reviews may test whether a recipient complies with "Federal civil rights laws or conscience protection laws", and so that agencies and pass-through entities may not require discretionary case-by-case approval of conscience or religious accommodation requests. That is the Quote's second limb - telling grantees their conscience obligations are a condition of funding - proposed but not final. **No withdrawal of funding from a violating entity is on the record, and the negative is now complete rather than blocked.** OCR's own chronological conscience action list (page reviewed 2026-04-30) was enumerated on 2026-09-03: the in-window entries are the April 2026 and January 2026 fact sheets, the Illinois Notice of Violation, the Safeguarding Federal Conscience Dear Colleague Letter, three January 2026 rescission and disavowal notices, and two 2025 Dear Colleague Letters on the Vaccines for Children Program. **The only funding-withdrawal action OCR has ever listed is "December 16, 2020, HHS to Disallow $200M in California Medicaid Funds…"** — five weeks before the window opened, itself withdrawn in 2021 and disavowed again on 2026-01-21. OCR's conscience newsroom (`/conscience/newsroom/index.html`, reviewed 2025-02-07) lists no news releases or bulletins at all, only a link to a 2018–2024 archive. And HHS-OIG has published nothing: `conscience` returns 0 reports and 0 Work Plan projects, both control-verified. Re-leveled `partial` in place on 2026-09-29 by owner decision, for the same reason: the proposed rule is a further step inside a rung the October 2025 Grants Policy Statement had already reached.
- Partially done
OCR issued a **Notice of Violation of the Weldon and Coats-Snowe Amendments to the State of Illinois**, read in full on 2026-09-03. It finds that the Illinois Health Care Right of Conscience Act as amended by P.A. 99-690 violates both Amendments, gives Illinois thirty days to say whether it will enforce the provision against objectors or take corrective action, and states that otherwise OCR "will forward this Notice of Violation and the evidence supporting OCR's findings in this matter to the appropriate HHS funding components for further action under applicable grants and contracts regulations … Such actions may ultimately result in suspensions, terminations, or other limitations on continued receipt of certain HHS funds." That is the enforcement step immediately short of the withdrawal the Quote asks for. Re-leveled `partial` in place on 2026-09-29 by owner decision: the October 2025 Grants Policy Statement had already put the item at `partial`, so this enforcement step is recorded within that rung rather than as a fall.
- Partially done
HHS's department-wide grant terms now tell every recipient that the federal conscience statutes bind the award. The HHS Grants Policy Statement, Version 2.0, effective 2025-10-01, was read in full on 2026-09-29. It is "incorporated by reference in the official Notice of Award (NoA) as a standard term and condition" and applies to all HHS discretionary awards except NIH's, and its Appendix D reaches non-discretionary awards too. Appendix D.4 lists the laws that "apply to all recipients and subrecipients". Among them, for the first time, is Discrimination Based on Religion and Religious Conscience: "Church Amendments, 42 USC 300a-7; Coates-Snowe Amendment, 42 USC 238n; and the Weldon Amendment", marked "See General Certifications and Representations", the certifications every applicant makes at SAM.gov registration. None of the three earlier editions (October 2024, April 2025, July 2025) mentions conscience or any of the three statutes. That delivers a piece of the Quote's second limb, grant instruments that inform grantees of their conscience obligations as a condition of funding, through ASFR's grants policy. It is `partial` and not `done`. NIH awards are outside it, and the funding announcements themselves were not changed to say so: the 2026 TPP NOFO's conscience section tells grantees what they are protected from, not what they must comply with. The first limb, withdrawing funding from a violator, is at `attempted`.
Research log
What was searched, and what didn’t count as evidence
Research notes
-
Full-text check of govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2026-05-29/html/2026-10817.htm (780 KB): 15 occurrences of “conscience”, including the proposed 2 CFR 200.300 revision and the section 200.513 compliance-review discussion.
-
HHS’s own conforming rulemaking is RIN 0991-AC46 Revisions to Subtitle B of Title 2 on Federal Financial Assistance (Proposed Rule Stage), a lead: https://www.reginfo.gov/public/do/eAgendaViewRule?pubId=202510&RIN=0991-AC46
-
Neither obstacle was real. hhs.gov can be read, and oig.hhs.gov’s search does filter when queried correctly — both were re-run on 2026-09-03. The enumeration is in the Status note above.
-
EO 14332 grant-process review (2026-09-29). Not an EO 14332 item. The order sets no conscience condition, and HHS’s Grants Policy Statement does not cite it. The review read HHS’s department-wide grant terms because the second limb of this Quote is a department-wide grant term. Read on 2026-09-29: the HHS grants-policies page and all four GPS editions it links (October 2024, April 2025, July 2025, October 2025), each extracted and searched for “conscience”, “Church Amendment”, “Weldon”, “300a-7” and “238n”. Only the October 2025 edition has any of them. Also read: the conscience section of NOFO AH-TP1-26-001 (“Protections for Healthcare Entities under Weldon and Other Conscience Protection Statutes”), which is a protection for grantees and not a compliance obligation.
-
Correction proposed, 2026-09-29. The two attempted events (2026-01-21, 2026-05-29) postdate the new 2025-10-01 partial, so the item still renders attempted, a fall that did not happen. The 2026-05-29 note’s reading of the second limb as “proposed but not final” missed that HHS’s own Grants Policy Statement had already listed the conscience statutes since 2025-10-01. The proposed fix keeps both events’ dates and Evidence and re-levels them partial in place.
- Action
- withdraw
- Object
- HHS funding to entities violating conscience laws
- ID
- 1391